54.3 F
Los Angeles
Friday, March 29, 2024

Trump Lawyer Resigns One Day Before Trial To Begin

Joseph Tacopina has filed with the courts that he will not represent Donald J. Trump. The E. Jean Carroll civil case is schedule to begin Tuesday January 16,...

Judge Lewis A. Kaplan Issues Order RE Postponement

On May 9, 2023, a jury found Donald J. Trump liable for sexual assault and defamation. The jury awarded Ms. Carroll $5 million in damages. Seven months ago,...

ASUS Announces 2023 Vivobook Classic Series

On April 7, 2023, ASUS introduced five new models in the 2023 Vivobook Classic series of laptops. The top laptops in the series use the 13th Gen Intel® Core™...
Technology CompaniesMicrosoftMicrosoft leads $24M investment in N-Trig

Microsoft leads $24M investment in N-Trig

The big news today is that Microsoft is leading a $24M investment in multi-touch digitizer maker N-Trig. Here’s the announcement from N-Trig. The Wall Street Journal has a write up here. It’s at the top of TechMeme too.

For the most part it looks like people are looking at this quite favorably and as a sign of Microsoft’s commitment to touch in Windows 7. It is. There’s no doubt that Microsoft needs to have hardware support for multi-touch and as of today N-Trig is a key player in this market and Microsoft needs to do all it can to help N-Trig and other digitizer companies.

I do, though, have a much more critical and different take on this whole thing–especially in light of the just ended CES show.

Here’s the deal. The N-Trig digitizer is the first true multi-touch digitizer on the market. It’s great because it supports capacitive touch as well as pen input. That’s wonderful for a Tablet PC. The Dell Tablet PC, for instance, uses it. However, there are some very well known problems with the N-Trig digitizer and let’s not forget the unbelievably high price that Dell is charging for it. Neither has been a good beginning for this technology. And there’s more. As of at least the M3 build of Windows 7 (I’m just getting back from CES so I haven’t had a chance to see if the experience is any better in the new beta build.) the alpha/beta N-Trig multi-touch driver for Windows 7 on the Dell is so bad it’s practically useless. Yes, useless. It’s no wonder that at almost every public Windows 7 multi-touch presentation now you see HP’s TouchSmart display being used and not the Dell.

Now I’m not saying that the N-Trig digitizer is junk. It’s not. What I am questioning is the commitment that N-Trig and even Microsoft have to making things work right. If it’s going to take $24M for N-Trig to write a good driver and get things right, then so be it. But come on. These Dell Tablet PC problems have been well known for what a year now and there’s no Dell/N-Trig fix and there’s currently no good N-Trig support for Windows 7. What is Microsoft rewarding here? Yeah, I’m being tough, but come on this is a big deal. Are we going to see a dribble of touch or a strong, first rate commitment to it?

The timing of this is interesting too. I think after the experiences with the N-Trig, there are many of us that are awaiting the Wacom capacitive digitizer. At CES Toshiba was showing a prototype M750 Tablet with the forthcoming device. My fingers are crossed that we’ll see a solid showing from Wacom here at a reasonable price.

And there’s the InPlay WriteSense capacitive technology too and its promises of providing a lower cost experience.

I have no hands on experience with either, but if I were Microsoft I’d be looking closely at these and other alternatives.

Last point: It looks like we need to do some educating here. I find it interesting that the Wall Street Journal in this article about N-Trig’s multi-touch product shows the TouchSmart displays. Uhm. The TouchSmart displays don’t use the N-Trig digitizer. They use NextWindows’ optical sensor, which provides a mere two-point touch.

Loren
Lorenhttp://www.lorenheiny.com
Loren Heiny (1961 - 2010) was a software developer and author of several computer language textbooks. He graduated from Arizona State University in computer science. His first love was robotics.

Latest news

Related news

1 COMMENT

1 Comment
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
trackback

[…] manufacturers of multitouch-capable touch panels already in use in a number of Tablet PCs, in what looks to be a strategy to boost hardware support for Windows 7’s upcoming multitouch support.  Back in […]