62.3 F
Los Angeles
Thursday, March 28, 2024

Trump Lawyer Resigns One Day Before Trial To Begin

Joseph Tacopina has filed with the courts that he will not represent Donald J. Trump. The E. Jean Carroll civil case is schedule to begin Tuesday January 16,...

Judge Lewis A. Kaplan Issues Order RE Postponement

On May 9, 2023, a jury found Donald J. Trump liable for sexual assault and defamation. The jury awarded Ms. Carroll $5 million in damages. Seven months ago,...

ASUS Announces 2023 Vivobook Classic Series

On April 7, 2023, ASUS introduced five new models in the 2023 Vivobook Classic series of laptops. The top laptops in the series use the 13th Gen Intel® Core™...
StaffIncremental BloggerOptoid: When Trivial Facts become Authentic

Optoid: When Trivial Facts become Authentic

Susan Brooks-Young argues that knowledge of historical facts does not measure whether she is a well educated person. She challenges the authenticity of televised street interviews that ask people to name the first five presidents of the United States.

So what? That bit of knowledge level information and $2.90 will get me a personal non-fat latte at the local Starbuck’s.

She argues that critical thinking and problem solving skills are more important than “rote learning.”

That argument continues. People can look up specific facts. They don’t have to memorize them to use them on demand.

However, trivial facts for one are “authentic,” vital facts for another. How can a teacher know in advance what is trivial for whom and what will save another person’s life in the future, even if everyone has access to Mobile PCs?

I agree that critical thinking and problem solving skills help us in everyday life. Both give priority to using rules of logic. And both rely on content provided from someplace.

For someone whose everday life involves solving problems that affect other people’s lives (that’s most of us), let’s hope we share a common perspective and don’t have to look everything up in order to hold a conversation. For example, I’m unclear what Brooks-Young means by the words “rote” and by “authentic.” More than one definition, short of professional jargon, exists for both.

I want my doctor to know and not have to look up my symptoms for a heart attack before acting to save my life.

I want public policy makers and implementers (including public school teachers) to know the history of civilization before they vote on legislation or instruct someone else on how to think.

To that end, I want teachers to insist that students can recite on demand key elements of that history, in part to insure that another generation of teachers will be well educated to help students develop critical thinking and problem solving skills.

Robert Heiny
Robert Heinyhttp://www.robertheiny.com
Robert W. Heiny, Ph.D. is a retired professor, social scientist, and business partner with previous academic appointments as a public school classroom teacher, senior faculty, or senior research member, and administrator. Appointments included at University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, Peabody College and the Kennedy Center now of Vanderbilt University; and Brandeis University. Dr. Heiny also served as Director of the Montana Center on Disabilities. His peer reviewed contributions to education include publication in The Encyclopedia of Education (1971), and in professional journals and conferences. He served s an expert reviewer of proposals to USOE, and on a team that wrote plans for 12 state-wide and multistate special education and preschools programs. He currently writes user guides for educators and learners as well as columns for TuxReports.com.

Latest news

Related news

  1. I do agree that if I’m having a heart attack, I want my doctor to know what to do without having to look up symptoms and remedies. However, in my mind, that’s having knowledge within a given context. Being asked to rattle off names of presidents, states and capitols, etc. is rote memorization with no context. Want students to identify and discuss the major accomplishment of each of the first five administrations in the U.S. Great! That means something. Just naming names doesn’t, don’t you think?