1. This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this site, you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Learn More.

Which external caddy for 2.5 external hard drive is the best?

Discussion in 'Notebooks' started by McGonigle, Apr 6, 2010.

  1. McGonigle

    McGonigle Flightless Bird

    Hi, I'm shopping for a good looking and reliable
    external 2.5'' caddy. I'll be obliged if anyone could
    recommend one . THANKS !
     
  2. Al Dykes

    Al Dykes Flightless Bird

    In article <8lHun.679116$5n1.363705@newsfe01.ams2>,
    McGonigle <mcgonigle@eu.org> wrote:
    >Hi, I'm shopping for a good looking and reliable
    >external 2.5'' caddy. I'll be obliged if anyone could
    >recommend one . THANKS !




    Reliability is good, but you have to plan for the fact that the *best*
    disk can die the day after you buy it and you must plan your computer
    procedures accordingly.

    I don't know what an "external caddy" is. I've just bought a Seagate
    FreeAgent USB disk (500M8).

    http://www.seagate.com/www/en-us/products/external/freeagent/

    There are several manufactures and I expect that they are all about
    the same. It's powered of the USB jack. It doesn't need a wall wart.








    --
    Al Dykes
    News is something someone wants to suppress, everything else is advertising.
    - Lord Northcliffe, publisher of the Daily Mail
     
  3. Barry Watzman

    Barry Watzman Flightless Bird

    They are all pretty much the same except for differences you can clearly
    see. The USB to {drive} conversion is just a single chip, and while
    there are different ones, you won't know which one any given product has
    and for the most part it doesn't matter.

    McGonigle wrote:
    > Hi, I'm shopping for a good looking and reliable external 2.5'' caddy.
    > I'll be obliged if anyone could recommend one . THANKS !
     
  4. McGonigle

    McGonigle Flightless Bird

    "Al Dykes" <adykes@panix.com> wrote in message
    news:hpfjo8$s4t$1@panix5.panix.com...
    > In article <8lHun.679116$5n1.363705@newsfe01.ams2>,
    > McGonigle <mcgonigle@eu.org> wrote:
    >>Hi, I'm shopping for a good looking and reliable
    >>external 2.5'' caddy. I'll be obliged if anyone could
    >>recommend one . THANKS !

    >
    > Reliability is good, but you have to plan for the fact that the *best*
    > disk can die the day after you buy it and you must plan your computer
    > procedures accordingly.
    >
    > I don't know what an "external caddy" is. I've just bought a Seagate
    > FreeAgent USB disk (500M8).
    >
    > http://www.seagate.com/www/en-us/products/external/freeagent/
    >
    > There are several manufactures and I expect that they are all about
    > the same. It's powered of the USB jack. It doesn't need a wall wart.
    >
    > --
    > Al Dykes
    > News is something someone wants to suppress, everything else is
    > advertising.
    > - Lord Northcliffe, publisher of the Daily Mail
    >

    Thanks ! As they almost the same I'll go for a reasonably priced one.
     
  5. Barry Watzman

    Barry Watzman Flightless Bird

    That would be about FIVE DOLLARS (US). Total, INCLUDING shipping. For
    an external USB 2.5" hard drive caddy (not including the drive itself).

    McGonigle wrote:

    >>

    > Thanks ! As they almost the same I'll go for a reasonably priced one.
     
  6. mike

    mike Flightless Bird

    Barry Watzman wrote:
    > They are all pretty much the same except for differences you can clearly
    > see. The USB to {drive} conversion is just a single chip, and while
    > there are different ones, you won't know which one any given product has
    > and for the most part it doesn't matter.

    I have several USB-ide/sata converters. For me, the chip does matter.
    Most won't read the SMART data from the drive. There doesn't seem to be any
    way to know until the boat from china actually delivers the unit.
    >
    > McGonigle wrote:
    >> Hi, I'm shopping for a good looking and reliable external 2.5''
    >> caddy. I'll be obliged if anyone could recommend one . THANKS !
     
  7. Barry Watzman

    Barry Watzman Flightless Bird

    Regarding the matter of whose chip is used in IDE-to-{SATA or IDE} adapters:

    Yes, there are subtle differences in some of the chips. But, first:

    1. The differences are usually VERY subtle and of no concern to MOST users.

    2. Regardless, in general, exactly as you pointed out, you have no way
    of either controlling or even knowing which chip is in ANY given adapter
    until you have the adapter physically in your hands and can open it and
    look (and, in some cases, even then because the chip markings are
    sometimes removed).

    So the matter becomes academic for most users in most situations.


    mike wrote:
    > Barry Watzman wrote:
    >> They are all pretty much the same except for differences you can
    >> clearly see. The USB to {drive} conversion is just a single chip, and
    >> while there are different ones, you won't know which one any given
    >> product has and for the most part it doesn't matter.

    > I have several USB-ide/sata converters. For me, the chip does matter.
    > Most won't read the SMART data from the drive. There doesn't seem to be
    > any
    > way to know until the boat from china actually delivers the unit.
    >>
    >> McGonigle wrote:
    >>> Hi, I'm shopping for a good looking and reliable external 2.5''
    >>> caddy. I'll be obliged if anyone could recommend one . THANKS !
     

Share This Page